A DILEMMA: What is the responsible thing to do when someone in the street displays behaviors that clearly indicate that he or she is mentally ill? We offer aid when anyone, stranger or acquaintance, is obviously experiencing physical distress. The man in my pictures was clearly in distress. Perhaps he was high on drugs. He wasn’t drunk. He didn’t ask for money. He begged for cigarettes. He took a rosary from around his neck and stooped to tie it around his ankle. He periodically took a feather from behind each ear and, holding them in his hands in what seemed like practiced ritual, he did a little dance. He didn't laugh or even smile. He reminded me of "Poor Tom," a figure of madness and poverty in King Lear. Dozens of people saw his distress. No one gave him anything. He wandered away... alone. Should I have done something? I would not have let a bleeding person wander away.
It’s clear that we ordinary citizens going about our own business prefer to let other ordinary citizens go about their business without interference; but in our dedication to the idea that “a person has the right to do” whatever he or she wants to do as long as it isn’t illegal and isn’t harmful to others, do we turn away when we should intervene?
It’s clear that we ordinary citizens going about our own business prefer to let other ordinary citizens go about their business without interference; but in our dedication to the idea that “a person has the right to do” whatever he or she wants to do as long as it isn’t illegal and isn’t harmful to others, do we turn away when we should intervene?